Petro Lakyda, director of the Institute of Forestry and Landscape-Park Management
Asking why we cut woods is like asking why we reap wheat
03.07.2020 16:10

This summer, the word “forest” has been probably the only one (except for an “epidemic”) that was used with anxiety and evoked sad associations.

Recently, the woods were on fire in Polissia. Now Ukraine’s western regions are flooded, as they say, due to uncontrolled deforestation. Every natural disaster is a conversation between nature and man. What does nature want to tell us this summer?

We will discuss this issue with Petro Lakyda, the director of the Education and Research Institute of Forestry and Landscape-Park Management at the National University of Life and Environmental Sciences of Ukraine.


- Petro Ivanovych, the president signed a law that introduces the concept of forest inventory. If such inventories are carried out, will we find any unpleasant details, and what are they?

- Let's start with what inventory is. In order to manage forestry so that it is both profitable, environmentally stable, and socially secure, we need to know what we are managing. Today, the Ukrainian state does not know how much forest it has, what its productivity, what volumes can be reasonably cut.

The entire civilized world carries out a statistical inventory of forests, using satellites, ground research, aircraft and drones as auxiliary tools.

Unfortunately, we have not had such research since 1996. We had one in 2011, and we refer to that data, which accounted for approximately 80 percent of forest. Therefore, an inventory is essential.

Ukraine has done a lot on inventory. There are two pilot projects, there are trained specialists. May God grant this law be implemented.

- In Japan, at the beginning of the 18th century, during the Tokugawa Shogunate, all trees were counted, certified and divided into valuable and non-valuable species. How is our forest statistics collected? It is possible, for example, with the help of a drone to calculate how many oaks, larch, yew groves we have?

- The question “how many trees do we have” is not correct. In the forest, no one ever counts them. At least no one counts every tree.

Although it is possible in private forests. Both in the United States and in EU countries, there are private forest owners who have small forest plots, and they have their own valuation methods. It can be done.

In Ukraine, forests managed by the State Forestry Agency are clearly divided into quarters. A quarter is divided into sections. There are sections with birch, oak and so on. In addition to statistical inventory, there is forest management. Once every 10 years, an expedition with cartographic documents and satellites works there. Actually, they assess the state of the forest at the moment and write a project for organizing forestry activity for another 10 years. Therefore, I can’t say that Ukraine has a poor statistics. Another question is that we have many forest users, and this complicates the process.

- Who are the forest users?

- The forest users are the State Forestry Agency of Ukraine, the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Ecology; they also have some national parks. The private forest sector is very small. In Sweden, there are about 70 percent of private forests. Our Constitution allows up to 5 hectares of isolated plots, or, if you have a land share, you can grow a forest there, but it must be legalized. But, on the other hand, if you have a share that is not cultivated, nature will take its course.

We have about 16.9% of the forest cover according to the 2011 inventory. This is a very low rate. Among European countries, we have the lowest forest cover percentage. But we have the same forest area as in Germany and Poland. We are a big country. But the forest cover (this is the ratio of areas covered by forest vegetation to the total land area or to the total area) is small.

- The phrase “bald Carpathians” is one of the most famous idioms of the Internet. Trees in the Carpathians are cut down, but some environmental experts or industry employees say that everything is not so bad and that forests are being restored. Are we exaggerating the danger?

- Forests in the Carpathians are really a problem, because in recent years many trees have dried up. In the time of the Austro-Hungarian Empire there were many mixed forests, they were cut down and only spruce or fir trees were planted. Pure fir was then very popular in European markets. They grew these trees, increased production. And what is monoculture? It is always harmful. Monoculture is mono-pests, mono-diseases. After the Second World War, many forests were cut down. But do not panic or demonize the entire industry: if we talk about corruption in Ukraine, the forest industry is practically not involved in this.

- Why?

- Because the forest sector does not even make up 1 percent of Ukraine’s GDP. You want to tell me that foresters are involved in big corruption if their contribution to GDP is 1 percent?

This is not an energy or agricultural holding. And the problem of forestry is a problem of development. We should look for new forestry methods, I would say we should be more friendly to nature.

For example, in the Czech Republic, forests are selectively cut down. Selection cutting requires roads, special cable installations for transporting trees. The state’s poverty does not allow this, and in recent years the situation in the forestry sector has been very critical. Earlier, the state contributed to the protection, restoration, conservation of forests from fires. Because foresters grow the forest, but when it becomes mature, it needs to be cut down or replaced. This is an economic component.

But there is another component: the forest is an environmental factor that gives us oxygen and stores carbon. I often have to argue with pseudo-ecologists who, without basic knowledge, protect every rotten log. I explained to them that while a tree grows it emits oxygen and stores carbon, if it has already died or is aging, the process of oxidation or decay is underway. And if you take this wood in time, make a table out of it, then this table actually conserved carbon for 50, 100 years. You also can recycle it. This method is widely used in Europe.

- Do you connect deforestation in the Carpathians with floods?

- No doubt, but to what extent. Of course, the forest is a serious regulator of water flow, but to a certain extent. The forest has a certain volume and can accumulate moisture. But when we have 70 percent of the monthly rainfall (as it was in Ivano-Frankivsk region in June), then, of course, the forest cannot retain moisture. The wooded area holds water better, but I do not share the opinion that deforestation itself has led to flooding.

- Recently, Ukraine has been at the center of a scandal, the essence of which is that the world's largest furniture retailer IKEA produces furniture from our beech illegally imported and sells it to us. How to combine business needs for valuable wood with forestry development? On the one hand, it is upsetting to be a carrier of corrupt practices, and on the other hand, how to find out if this is fake or not?

- There is a serious market struggle. IKEA is a huge, powerful manufacturer of cheap furniture, and not just furniture. We have a big problem with our legislation. There is the so-called law of silence (the period when wood cutting is prohibited), but there are gaps in its interpretation. Yesterday I read the report of this international organization (the British environmental organization Earthsight), and I do not think that such a large industrial giant, which invests enormously in ecology, social programs, will neglect its image for the sake of illegal wood. Perhaps there are some violations; I'm not a guarantor of order. But I think the problem is in our legislation when beech forests were cut down during the silence season, and this, according to our law, is illegal logging. But I do not believe that someone could come without documents, cut down the forest and sell it to IKEA – this is impossible because they very seriously monitor the supply chain from forest to a plant or a consumer and spend a lot of money on this. I can’t guarantee the legitimacy of actions of all foresters, all managers (in a corrupt country there cannot be only one branch that is not corrupt), but it would be wrong to assume that domestic corruption is rooted in forestry and its managers.

- And how to combine business interest with environmental one?

- Those who manage the forest industry should develop such legislation that we have a resource and that we do not lose the environmental component, as well as the social component so that people do not block logging roads. The state should regulate all this, starting with the Verkhovna Rada with its laws and ending with the Cabinet of Ministers and the State Forestry Agency, which is instructed to manage more than 70 percent of the forests.

- In Davos, people wanted to plant 1 trillion trees as part of the fight against climate change. We picked up the idea that we supposedly plant 1 million trees in one day. Firstly, is it worth doing it in one day, is that right? Secondly, is it easy to plant 1 million trees?

- One million trees is a political action, a slogan that needs to be supported in every way. Trees should be planted; it's not up for discussion. Is it possible to plant a million trees simultaneously? Today it is very difficult, but it needs to be done. In a day or a few days or weeks: I do not want to criticize either intention or idea. Between the second half of March and mid-April, when the growing season begins, trees should be planted. This is a short period - and it is not easy to do. Foresters also adapt to this.

In Europe, foresters plant containerized tree seedlings, and they can be planted all year round.

Lana Samokhvalova, Kyiv

Photo credit: Yevhen Kotenko

While citing and using any materials on the Internet, links to the website not lower than the first paragraph are mandatory. In addition, citing the translated materials of foreign media outlets is possible only if there is a link to the website and to the website of a foreign media outlet. Citing and using materials in offline media, mobile apps, Smart TV are allowed only with written permission from Ukrinform. News and publications marked as "Advertisement" and "PR" and articles in the section "Releases" include promoted content, and an advertiser is responsible for the content.

© 2015-2020 Ukrinform. All rights reserved.

Website design Studio Laconica

Extended searchHide extended search
By period: